topics

Low fat, full fat: Why the diet industry keeps changing its mind

“The simple secret of intermittent fasting!” “The paleo way is the only way!” “Six weeks to a super you!”

However, despite the barrage of diet books, the expansion of nutrition research and the growth of education about healthy living, global obesity has more than doubled since 1980.

It may be that this is due to the conflicting information constantly issued from the diet industry. “Eat lots of protein – it’ll speed up your metabolism!” “Too much protein will damage your kidneys – reduce your protein intake!” “Superfoods are a vital source of antioxidants!” “Superfoods aren’t so super at all!” “Don’t snack it will make you pile on the pounds!” “You should snack – it’ll stop you from binge eating!” It’s no wonder people aren’t sure what to eat.

The UK launched its first dietary guidelines in 1994, which have since been continuously revised to form the guide now known as “The Eatwell Plate”. The dietary guidelines recommend plentiful carbohydrates “such as rice, bread, pasta and potatoes”, at least five portions of fruits and vegetables, some protein, some milk, some dairy and minimal saturated fat.

However, a recent report serves to highlight the confusion consumers face when it comes to food: it claims that the official advice on low-fat diets is outright wrong, even damaging.

Led by the National Obesity Forum and the Public Health Collaboration, the report (not peer-reviewed, it’s worth noting) attacked a host of official health proposals. It claims that “eating fat does not make you fat”, and criticises Eatwell Plate’s small fat allowance. The report also stated that saturated fats have been unfairly demonised, as there is allegedly little evidence to suggest that they cause heart disease. Meanwhile sugar consumption should be dialled down to zero, apparently, and calories shouldn’t be counted, as an abundance of them won’t cause obesity. Also, forget about the exercise - apparently a bad diet can’t be outrun, according to the report.

Professor David Haslam, chairman of the National Obesity Forum, said: “As a clinician, treating patients all day every day, I quickly realised that guidelines from on high, suggesting high-carbohydrate, low-fat diets were the universal panacea, were deeply flawed. Current efforts have failed – the proof being that obesity levels are higher than they have ever been, and show no chance of reducing despite the best efforts of government and scientists.”

Dr Aseem Malhotra, consultant cardiologist and founding member of the Public Health Collaboration reinforced this by saying the guidelines were “perhaps the biggest mistake in modern medical history, resulting in devastating consequences for public health.” Under current dietary guidelines, obesity levels have indeed increased in the UK, with nearly two-thirds of men and women overweight or obese, costing the economy more than £3bn per year.

In the face of such starkly opposed sides - both backed by seemingly reputable experts who claim all their research is based on empirical evidence - what are consumers meant to do?

THE VILIFICATION OF FAT:

In 1983, it was recommended that overall dietary fat consumption should make up only 30 per cent of total daily energy intake – 10 per cent of which, at most, should come from saturated fat.

The recommendations came from a number of research papers published at the time, which suggested a link between saturated fat intake and increased levels of LDL cholesterol – the cholesterol which has been connected to increased risk of heart disease, stroke and atherosclerosis.

An even simpler reason for the suggestions boiled down to this: fat has more calories per gram than carbohydrates – nine calories per gram versus four, to be exact. This shape to future official guidelines, and gave birth to the low-fat high-carbohydrate mantra. Fat was cemented as public enemy number one.

As a result, the fat eliminated from people’s diets was to be supplemented with an increased intake of carbohydrates. Tipping the scales in favour of carbohydrates were promises of weight loss as a result of higher fibre content, elevated levels of serotonin to aid sleep and boosts in mood from feeling fuller.

But obesity levels continued to soar, and health experts shifted their focus to the next culprit: carbs.

THE LOW-CARB ERA :

An analysis by The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition combined the results of 21 studies and found that “saturated fat was not associated with an increased risk of coronary heart disease”. Other studies demonstrated the positive effect on testosterone levels in men from increased saturated fat intake, and have noted increased levels of triglycerides (the stuff that makes you fat) from lower fat diets.

As a result, dieticians developed a deep suspicion of carbs, and sugar in particular, and diets like the Atkins regime became more and more popular.

In part, the report by the National Obesity Forum and Public Health Collaboration uses the research that propped up these low-carb high-fat diets as a means by which to attack the general consensus surrounding healthy eating. Dr Malhotra, who led the latest report, previously worked in a pressure group called Action on Sugar – a group that has tried to get the food industry to reduce the amount of sugar added to food.

The reasoning goes something like this: guidelines encouraging greater carbohydrate consumption are oblivious to the fact that sugars constitute a vast amount of refined carbohydrates. By cranking up the sugar intake we ratchet up the risk of type 2 diabetes; this in turn could spark further health problems including obesity.

The logic seems sound, and yet obesity levels have continued to soar in the face of this research. The notion that all sugar should be avoided also ignores the fact that our brains require a significant amount of glucose for optimal functioning.

EVERYTHING IN MODERATION :

In the face of an industry that can’t make up its mind about how people should eat, it’s no wonder obesity levels have grown to epidemic proportions. So what can be done?

Professor Susan Jebb, the government’s obesity adviser, believes that the current debate needs to expand beyond the battle between carbohydrates and fat. She said: “We’re eating too many calories – if we want to tackle obesity people do need to eat fewer calories and that means less fat and less sugar.” And she’s right. If decades of research have pointed to anything assertively, it’s that calories count, and paying attention to portion sizes could take us a long way.

Both fat and carbohydrates are necessary for our bodies to function. The solution? Enjoy everything in moderation. Eat fruits without fearing fructose, don’t throw away the egg yolk, get a decent amount of protein and yes, you should have your slice of cake too.

Source : http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/health/2016/05/low-fat-full-fat-why-diet-industry-keeps-changing-its-mind

Main Topics of Buddy

QHEALTH
Diet & Nutrition

 

View All

Diet & Nutrition
QHEALTH
Exercise & Fitness

View All

Exercise & Fitness
QHEALTH
Mind & Body

View All

Mind & Body
QHEALTH
Lifestyle Diseases

View All

Lifestyle Diseases
QHEALTH
Workplace Wellness

View All

Workplace Wellness
QHEALTH
Patient experience vs. patient care...

Healthcare isn't Disney World

"Patients shouldn't have an experience; [patients] have problems...

View All

Patient experience vs. patient...
QHEALTH
Why Leisure is Actually So Important

When was the last time you had time for yourself doing things that you really enjoy? This is something you probably may...

View All

Why Leisure is Actually So...
QHEALTH
Women Wellness Secrets

View All

Women Wellness Secrets
QHEALTH
Preventive Health

Remember the old saying that "an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure"? This can be especially true...

View All

Preventive Health
QHEALTH
Spare an Hour to Save a Life

View All

Spare an Hour to Save a Life
QHEALTH
Children Health

View All

Children Health
QHEALTH
Nipah

  • Nipah Virus is a newly emerging zoonosis that causes a severe disease in both animals and humans.
  • T...

  • View All

    Nipah
    QHEALTH
    Why You Should Opt for NABH Quality...

    One would rarely call a hospital an ideal place to be in, simply because it’s associated with a feeling of uneasi...

    View All

    Why You Should Opt for NABH...
    QHEALTH
    What is NABL & What Are Its Benefits

    What is NABL?

    The National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories (NABL) is...

    View All

    What is NABL & What Are Its...
    QHEALTH
    6 Secrets You Didn’t Know About Yog...

    Any Yoga practitioner would agree that Yoga is not just a practice but a way of living. Since its originatio...

    View All

    6 Secrets You Didn’t Know...
    QHEALTH
    4 Useful Tips to Avoid Dehydration Th...

    Summer is finally here, but for better or worse, so is the intense heat that it brings. Over the past few ye...

    View All

    4 Useful Tips to Avoid Dehydration...
    Registered Member
    Hospital Forgot Password Request
    Enter your registered Email ID to reset password
    Forgot Password Request
    Enter your registered Email ID to reset password
    search
    looking in Modify